12 Days of Cookies: Chocolate Peppermint Cups ☃️ (Day 4!)


Happy Friday Reader!

Today's holiday confection...

Chocolate Peppermint Cups

Why We Love Them

These are just like a peppermint patty that's cosplaying as a peanut butter cup...and they're so cute!

The center is a cool, peppermint, Oreo-like filling that's laced with crunchy bits of peppermint candy that's then encased in dark chocolate (feel free to use milk chocolate, semi-sweet chocolate or whatever chocolate floats your boat).

These are assembled and chilled in under an hour...what could be dreamier?!

Can We Ship 'Em?

If you want to ship these I recommend tempering the chocolate. King Arthur Baking has a great tempering guide for reference.

Make-Ahead Options

These are a perfect make-ahead treat!

If the chocolate isn't tempered (it's not in the recipe), store them in the fridge in an air-tight container. Set them out on the counter 15 minutes prior to serving.

They'll last in the fridge for about 2 weeks.

More Tips

  1. Muffin Liners. You can use any standard muffin liner for the recipe. Don't trim prior to filling with chocolate...it's a disaster. After the cups are finished and have set, then trim the excess muffin liner with some sharp scissors.
  2. Flourish. I don't believe that Williams-Sonoma still sells the candy cane sprinkles from the photos. I found these Candy Cane Sprinkles on Amazon. But I also think crushed candy canes, sprinkled along one side, would be so cute!
  3. Refined Coconut Oil. Yes, these have veggie shortening in the chocolate (to keep it soft) and shortening in the filling (for those Oreo vibes). Can you substitute with refined coconut oil? Yes, yes you can.

That's it with these, they're so easy, fun and delicious!

As always, leave any questions, comments, recipe notes on the actual recipe post and I'll respond asap. 💗

Happy baking!!



Rebecca's 12 Days of Cookies

Day One: Candy Cane Brownies

Day Two: Chocolate Rye Cookies with Cherries

Day Three: Iced Old-Fashioned Oatmeal Cookies



"Following up on her acclaimed debut, The Cookie Book, writer, photographer, and recipe developer Rebecca Firth tackles cake in her new book. You may have trouble picking which recipe to start with: Chocolate Stout Cake with Champagne Buttercream or a tart, sticky Glazed Tangerine Donut Cake?”
Epicurious, 25 New Baking Books for Cozy Fall Treats

"Writer, photographer and queen of cookies, Rebecca Firth teases my sweet tooth and I am not mad about it. Love following her and her tempting creations and can't wait to see what she comes up with next."
―Tiffani Thiessen, actress and author of Pull Up a Chair

Food & Wine, Best Baking Cookbooks to Own Right Now

DisplacedHousewife | Really Delicious, Well-Tested Sweets

Join me for all things sweet including lots of cookies (my fav!), brown butter, chocolate, caramel, cakes and more! I love treats ranging from quickie weeknight cravings to fun, weekend baking projects. xo

Read more from DisplacedHousewife | Really Delicious, Well-Tested Sweets

Hi Reader! If you’re looking for the ultimate back pocket Easter dessert, stop here! These Malted Chocolate Brownies are everything a holiday treat should be: fudgy, chewy, beautiful and loaded with the perfect chocolate malt flavor. No fussy pastel frostings or complicated layers—just two bowls, a whisk, and a pile of malted eggs! I hope you're having a wonderful Wednesday! Let's Make Malted Brownies! Salted Peanut Butter Cup Cookies Peanut butter cup lovers unite! You're going to love this...

Hi Reader! I wanted to send this recipe out on a Wednesday so you'd have time to get your madeleine pans for this weekend (if you don't already have some!). If you’ve ever struggled to get that iconic "hump" on your Madeleines, I have the 4-step solution for you: A cold batter, a hot oven, chilled madeleine pan and an overnight rest (not in this order!). Why these are fab: The "Moisture Seal": Half are dipped in dark chocolate and half in a fresh strawberry glaze. The coating traps the...

Hi Reader! 'Tis the season for the most fabulous cake we could ever ask for! Picture this: a breezy, one-bowl chocolate cake made with Guinness (or any malted beer). The crumb is light and bouncy, and the flavor is rich and chocolaty. This 9-inch (23-cm) round cake is mixed and baked in just 45 minutes (!!). Top it with my favorite 5-minute chocolate malt frosting, and it’s the perfect treat for March. Honestly, I make this cake year-round because it’s the perfect celebration cake—or simply a...